The NvelopIQ team · · 8 min read

Using REScheck to bid less foam and still pass code

Most spray foam crews treat the energy code as a minimum to clear with room to spare. Deeper on the deck, closed cell where open cell would do, “to be safe.” It works. It also hands the job to the competitor who ran the numbers and bid less foam.

REScheck software is how you run those numbers. Here is how the check works, where foam depth actually moves the result, and how to use it to bid tighter without risking a fail.

What REScheck actually checks

REScheck is the U.S. Department of Energy’s free tool for showing that a house meets the residential energy code. Most jobs use its trade-off method, which compares two numbers:

  • The code house: your house, with every wall, ceiling and window at exactly the U-factor the code’s prescriptive table allows.
  • Your house: the same house, with the assemblies you actually plan to build.

For each assembly, area × U-factor gives a heat-loss number, and adding them up gives the house’s total UA. If your total UA is at or below the code house’s, you pass. REScheck reports how far you are over or under, in percent.

The important part: it’s the total that has to pass, not each wall on its own. A little better in one place can make up for a little worse in another, within the limits your code edition sets.

Why that matters for foam

On the prescriptive path, every surface has to hit its table value. On the trade-off path, you only need the house as a whole to pass. That gives you room to put foam where it does the most good per dollar.

Three things decide where that is:

  1. Area. A surface with a lot of square feet moves the total UA a lot. Each inch on a big surface counts more.
  2. Diminishing returns. Going from R-13 to R-20 drops the U-factor much more than going from R-38 to R-45. The first inches buy the most.
  3. Price per R. Open cell costs less per board foot but gives roughly R-3.5 to R-3.9 per inch. Closed cell gives roughly R-6 to R-7 per inch at a higher price. Check your product’s data sheet for the real numbers.

Put those together and a pattern shows up. Thin foam everywhere fails. The maximum everywhere passes by a mile and costs the most. Somewhere in between is a package that passes for the least money, and it’s often not the one a crew would pick by feel.

A worked example

Take a made-up house with 1,600 sf of walls and a 2,100 sf sealed roof deck. Using example R-values and example installed rates (not real prices):

Walls Roof deck Result Foam cost
3.5” open cell 5.5” open cell Fails $7,718
3.5” open cell 9.5” open cell Fails, barely $11,498
5.5” open cell 7” open cell Passes $10,575
5.5” open cell 11.5” open cell Passes easily $14,828

The “to be safe” package in the last row passes, and costs about $4,250 more than the cheapest one that passes. That gap is your bid margin, or the bid you lose to the crew that found it.

Notice that the cheapest pass added depth on the walls, not the roof. In this house, going deeper on the roof deck kept chasing diminishing returns, and two more inches of open cell on the walls did more for less. Every house is different, and that’s the point: you have to run it to know.

Simplified example, made-up house, illustrative R-values and rates. You can try it yourself on our REScheck page.

Count every real layer, and nothing fake

An assembly’s U-factor is more than the foam. Sheathing, stucco, brick veneer, drywall and air films all add a little R-value. Count them honestly and you may find the house passes with less foam than you thought.

Don’t go the other way. Inflating an R-value, adding layers that aren’t on the plans, or skipping the framing in a wall will get a “pass” on paper and a problem at inspection. The check is only useful if the inputs match the house.

Open cell first

Because open cell is usually the cheaper way to add R-value, a good search tries open cell first and only reaches for closed cell where it is needed: a place where depth is limited, where the code or the building science calls for an air-impermeable layer, or where it really is cheaper per point of UA.

Keep in mind that the UA math isn’t the whole code. Rules for unvented attics, vapor retarders and ignition barriers still apply whatever REScheck says. Treat them as fixed, then let the trade-off decide the rest.

How to sell it to the builder

Builders hear “we can do it cheaper” all the time. What they don’t hear often is “and here’s the compliance report that shows it passes.” Bring the report with the bid. It answers the question before they ask it, and it makes your lower number look like expertise instead of corner-cutting.

If the house also needs HVAC sizing, the same envelope is the starting point. A foam house usually needs less tonnage than a rule of thumb says. More on that in Why foam houses need smaller HVAC.

Where NvelopIQ fits

NvelopIQ’s REScheck runs on the same upload as your spray foam takeoff. It works in every state, uses real assemblies, and gives you a compliance report plus a REScheck-Web compatible import file. When the house fails, it shows the cheapest ways to pass, open cell first, with depth added where it counts.

Your local code official has the final word on compliance, and you review every result before it goes out.


REScheck and REScheck-Web are tools of the U.S. Department of Energy. NvelopIQ is not affiliated with, endorsed by or certified by DOE.

Measure less. Bid more.

The private beta is open to spray foam and insulation contractors. Bring a real plan set and see what comes back.

Join the beta Sample